I have been following the debate about guns, both about
rights and violence. Both sides have valid points and there seems to be no
middle ground. The extremes on both sides of the issue make it almost
impossible to reach a logical solution. To make matters worse their paranoia is
fueled by each others rhetoric. Those who propose a reasonable plan to provide
for both gun rights and public safety are shot down by both sides.
As a Libertarian I have a strong belief in the second amendment
and as a Mayor responsible for public safety I am concerned about the people
who are willing to do violence like that of Sandy Hook and Boston. It is a tough issue to deal with. The
people who suffered the trauma of those kinds of actions require some action to
stop it from happening again.
The Second Amendment states:
“A well regulated Militia, being
necessary to the security of a free
State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms,
shall not be infringed.”
When this amendment was crafted the new United States of America
relied totally on the state militia to fight wars. Each state militia required
its citizens to provide their own weapons which at that time were muskets. The
federal army was very small and not well provided for by congress. Times have
changed. Today the state militia is called the National Guard and is well
provided for by both federal and state governments, as modern weapons of war
are more complicated. We are still relying on them to fight wars. The Second
Amendment was designed for our national defense. The up shot of well armed
citizenry is that any nations that would dear to send troops to invade us would
be met by gun fire from almost every house and cave. I know private citizens
who are very good shots.
The other side of the coin is the violence that seems to be
happening with greater frequency every year. How do we deal with that issue? I
do note that not all of it is committed with guns but a lot of it has been.
This is a difficult issue for all of us as a greater population has produced
more violent people, most of them men. There have always been angry violent men
in this world who enjoy killing people. Ad to that the testosterone poisoning
that makes young adult males so aggressive and you have problems. One way or
another they will make trouble. They will find someone to sell them guns,
purchase enough fireworks to make bombs or use knives to kill innocent people
just because they can. How can we control this problem that is now world wide?
Some how we need to be able to think this through and it
will not be easy unless both sides of the issue are willing to come to the
table and talk sense and at this point that is not happening. We do not need to
collect and destroy guns and no one is really trying to do that even though the
fear mongers are raising that idea for gun owners to react about. Perhaps the
term “Well Regulated Militia” has some room for regulating who can legally
purchase weapons of the military variety as some people should not have them. Is
it possible to register guns in such a way so that if a gun is used in a crime
they can be traced with out people fearing that registering their guns will be
used against them? The tricky part is protecting everyone else’s right at the
same time. Public safety is important but so is our constitutional rights and
both need to be addressed. I doubt that our congress is able to do that any
time soon.